Do You Pay Taxes on Unemployment?

Do You Pay Taxes on Unemployment?
••• Pra-chid/iStock/GettyImages

The federal government threw a safety net out to millions of Americans in 2020 in response to the coronavirus pandemic. According to AARP, ​10.7 million workers​ were still unemployed as of December 2020, largely due to the virus. The government responded by tweaking unemployment insurance provisions for those who found themselves out of work.

Unfortunately, this gift didn’t come without a string attached, one that some recipients might not be aware of: Unemployment compensation is taxable income under the terms of the U.S. tax code. You have to report this income on your 2020 tax return if you received it. It’s only subject to income tax, however. You don’t have to pay FICA taxes on it – Social Security and Medicare.

Unemployment Compensation That’s Taxable

The Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security (CARES) Act was passed on March 27, 2020, and it provided for legislation that would beef up benefits for the unemployed. The Act provided unemployed Americans with an additional ​$600​ a week in unemployment compensation. Then additional legislation passed in December provided for an additional ​$300​ a week through March 14, 2021.

The CARES Act created the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA) program to extend unemployment eligibility to individuals who wouldn’t otherwise have qualified for assistance, namely the self-employed. The Pandemic Emergency Unemployment Compensation (PUEC) program gave taxpayers an additional ​13 weeks​ of benefits.

All this income is taxable, and taxation isn’t limited to these extra federal provisions. Regular unemployment compensation provided by states from the Federal Unemployment Trust Fund or from their own programs, railroad unemployment benefits, and disability benefits paid in lieu of unemployment compensation are all considered taxable income, too. This is the case every year, regardless of a pandemic.

Some Exceptions to the Rule

A few slim loopholes exist to the rules regarding what compensation is taxable. According to the IRS, your benefits aren’t taxable if you contributed to a government unemployment program, and you received no tax break in return. You paid in with after-tax dollars, and you don’t claim a tax deduction for the sum.

The same rule applies to private, nonunion compensation funds and to special union funds. Benefits received up to the amount of your contributions are tax free, but they’re included in your taxable income otherwise.

You’re also in the clear if you received benefits from a fund financed by your employer, provided that you didn’t also contribute. This isn’t considered unemployment compensation, although it ​is​ income, so it’s also subject to income tax, Social Security tax, and Medicare tax, just as regular wages would be.

How to Report Benefits

You should receive a Form 1099-G, “Certain Government Payments,” from your state sometime during the month of January for unemployment compensation you received in the previous year. The amount of benefits you received appears in Box 1. This is the amount you should report on Line 7 of Schedule 1 that goes with your tax return. The total of Schedule 1, which also includes other forms of compensation, is then transferred to Line 8 on your 2020 Form 1040 tax return.

The IRS warns that it doesn’t mean that your benefits are not taxable if you don’t receive a Form 1099-G for some reason. Go to your state’s website and access an electronic copy of the form from there.

Options for Payment: Withholding

You have the option of having income tax withheld from your benefits, just as your employer would withhold taxes from your paycheck, if you’re still collecting unemployment compensation or if you should find that it becomes necessary going forward. Just ask the paying office for a Form W-4V, complete it and return it to them. Not all states are set up to provide this service, however, and you have to ask. They won’t withhold taxes automatically.

It might turn out that you had enough withheld from your regular earnings before you were laid off to cover both that and at least a portion of your unemployment benefits, particularly if you were laid off toward the end of the tax year. These withholdings would cover both types of income. Withholding doesn't have to come directly from your benefits.

But keep in mind that withholding from unemployment is capped at ​10 percent​. You can’t have ​20 or 30 percent​ withheld to compensate retroactively for unemployment income you received before you knew this was an option. The total amount withheld appears in Box 4 of your Form 1099-G. Withholding amounts and estimated payments you made are entered on the second page of Form 1040, subtracting from the amount of tax that’s due on the return.

Quarterly Estimated Tax Payments

You also have the option of making estimated tax payments to the IRS, sending in more than the allowed ​10 percent​ instead of having the state withhold taxes on your behalf. You can make payments on the IRS Direct Pay website – just note on the drop down menu that you’re making an estimated tax payment and indicate the year for which you’re paying. You can also print out Form 1099-ES and send it in with a paper check.

And, of course, you can have extra sums withheld from your paychecks if you should return to work before the end of the tax year in question. The important thing is that you get your tax payments to the IRS as early as possible, because late payment penalties and added interest can apply to tax debts that linger.

If You Simply Can’t Pay

Ideally, you already knew all this and took steps to pay as you were battling your way through the nightmare that was 2020, but all’s not lost if you find yourself faced with a nasty, unexpected tax bill when you prepare your return. You were collecting unemployment compensation for a reason, so you might not have a healthy savings account to fall back on.

Contact the IRS and ask about an installment payment program. You can also apply on the IRS website. The agency provides a few payment options when taxpayers simply can’t afford to pay in a timely manner. You’ll have to pay interest, but it will be less than if you simply didn’t pay, and any financial penalties might be forgiven. The worst thing you can do is ignore the dilemma. The IRS will work with you if you have no other reasonable options.

Be sure to at least file your tax return on time, even if you can’t come up with the money right away. The financial penalties for failure to file are worse than the penalties for failure to pay.

Most States Tax Unemployment, Too

The unfortunate reality is that you might not be done with all this when you figure out what you owe the IRS. Most states tax unemployment compensation as well. Only Oregon, California, Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Virginia do not, according to AARP.

Of course, it’s also possible that you live in one of the states that don't have an income tax at all. As of 2021, these states are:

  • Alaska
  • Washington
  • Nevada
  • Wyoming
  • South Dakota
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • Florida

Additionally, New Hampshire taxes only interest and dividend income.