Checklist for an I-9 Self Audit

by Anna Assad ; Updated July 27, 2017
A birth certificate may be reviewed by an employer for an I-9.

Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification, is required under federal law and must be completed by employers for all new hires after November 11, 1986. The purpose of the I-9 form is to verify that the employee is legally allowed to work in the United States, per the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. An employer who does not have complete I-9 forms on file for employees is subject to criminal and civil penalties.

Verify Form Information

All of the employee's personal information should be filled out completely on the I-9 form and match data from the company's personnel records. If the employee is an alien authorized to work until a certain date, the date must be entered on the form. The full name, Social Security number, address and date of birth of the employee must be entered on the I-9. If the employee does not yet have a Social Security number, "None" should be checked on the form. The section where the employee attests to his citizenship status needs to have the appropriate box checked, and the I-9 must be signed and dated by the employee. A translator who assisted the employee in filing out the form must have completed and signed the "Translator/Preparer" section of the I-9.

Documentation Check

The employee must provide either one document from "List A" on the form or one document each for "List B" and "List C" to the employer for examination. The document types for each list are specified on the instructions for the I-9 form. List A items include a passport and permanent resident card; List B documents include a driver's license and school ID card; and List C documents include a birth certificate and Social Security card. The I-9 form should be checked to ensure sufficient documents were presented and the employer marked the type, expiration date and any numbers listed on the documents given.

Validate Employer Certification and Reverification

The employer certification section of the I-9 form, which attests to the verification of the employee's documents, must be completed and dated. The I-9 form should have been completed within three days of the employee's hire.If the employee was an alien authorized to work until a specific date or quit and was rehired, the I-9 must be updated to reflect re-authorization. Section 3 of the I-9 must be completed by the employer and include the rehire date or the new document that extends the work authorization.

About the Author

Anna Assad began writing professionally in 1999 and has published several legal articles for various websites. She has an extensive real estate and criminal legal background. She also tutored in English for nearly eight years, attended Buffalo State College for paralegal studies and accounting, and minored in English literature, receiving a Bachelor of Arts.

Photo Credits

  • C Squared Studios/Photodisc/Getty Images