The Advantages & Disadvantages of Capital Gains Tax

The Advantages & Disadvantages of Capital Gains Tax
••• boonchai wedmakawand/Moment/GettyImages

A capital gain is profit earned on capital assets such as securities investments and real estate. When an investor purchases a capital asset at a certain amount and sells the asset for a higher amount, a capital gain is the result. A capital-gains tax is assessed when a capital asset is sold for profit. Many investors utilize strategic techniques for taking a capital gain or loss depending on their individual tax needs. Capital-gains taxes have both benefits and drawbacks, depending on the tax situation of the taxpayer.


  • Some advantages of the capital gains tax are that you can defer it until you sell your asset and that you may pay less tax is it's a long-term gain vs. a short-term gain. Downsides include profit reduction, a higher tax rate for short-term gains and double taxation.

Tax Deferment

One advantage of capital gains taxes is that tax payments are deferred until the asset is sold. For example, a real-estate investor does not pay taxes on the equity gained in a property investment until the year he sells the property for a profit. Further, a securities investor does not pay capital-gains taxes on profits earned from stocks and bonds until he takes a distribution or sells the assets. Investors only pay taxes during the tax year they realize the gain. This is different than income taxes where you must pay a tax each time you receive an income payment.

Profit Reduction

According to the Internal Revenue Service, nearly everything you own for personal use or investment purposes is a capital asset. A drawback to owning capital assets is that if they are sold for profit, the IRS requires that you report gains as income. The disadvantage of this tax is that it can reduce the overall profits realized from the sale of the asset.

Tax Rates

The amount of taxes you must pay on a capital gain depends on the length of time you owned the asset prior to selling and can either be a benefit or detriment to the taxpayer. If you owned the asset longer than 12 months and realize a profit, you have a long-term capital gain, which is taxed at a lower rate. If you own an asset less than 12 months and sell it for a profit, you have a short term capital gain, which is taxed at a higher rate. Long-term capital-gains taxes are more advantageous than short-term capital-gains taxes because the rate typically produces savings.

For 2018, long-term capital gains tax rates vary between 0 and 20 percent, depending on the taxpayer's income tax bracket. For example, those in the 10 or 15 percent tax brackets pay a long-term capital gains rate of 0 percent, while those in the 39.6 percent bracket pay the full 20 percent. Certain special categories have their own capital gains rates. For example, an unrecaptured section 1250 gain is taxed at 25 percent; gains on collectibles and certain types of small business stock are taxed at 28 percent, while short-term capital gains are always taxed at ordinary income rates.

You can use tax losses to offset capital gains and up to $3,000 of ordinary income. However, if you're selling stock to capture a tax loss, avoid buying it back within 30 days, or the loss will be disallowed per IRS wash sale rules.

Double Taxation

Taxpayers are responsible for paying federal, and in many cases, state capital-gains taxes. Property owners and investors, for example, must report capital gains from the sale of real estate on both federal and state income-tax returns in most states. The additional tax on the state level is a disadvantage for many taxpayers.